Part of the Gig
Published: November 22, 2026
By Steven Boardman | MMA Stalker Shane Carwin had an engineering degree from the Colorado School of Mines. By October 2024, he told a federal court that he could no longer concentrate well enough to hold an engineering job. He needed healthcare and help paying for food, shelter and transportation. He was supporting a settlement with the UFC, and he told the court what it meant to wait for the money. Years from now, he said, it might be of no use to him. He had company. Jorge Rivera had no health insurance and could not afford the care he needed. Wanderlei Silva described his fear that he had suffered traumatic brain injury, along with symptoms affecting his mental health. Cung Le, whose name the case carried, described relying on a friend for necessities. Jessica Aguilar, a former UFC strawweight, said she had no health insurance and had deferred her own care because of the expense. She said she suffered what she called a “mini stroke” after her final UFC bout, during which she was repeatedly poked in the left eye. The fighters gave these accounts in support of the settlement, explaining why a prompt resolution mattered to people whose health and finances were already failing. The case concerned allegedly suppressed pay. The supporting paperwork had become a record of what happens to fighters who can no longer earn a living once their careers end. There is something obscene about that sequence. You spend your working life absorbing damage for a business that sells the spectacle, and then find yourself waiting on a lawsuit about your wages so you can afford to deal with the consequences. Meanwhile the promotion keeps booking fights, selling tickets and celebrating the performances you gave it. Your family gets the appointments, the bills and the harder job of helping you through the day. Wanderlei Silva supplied the epilogue. Less than a year after his fears of brain injury reached a federal courtroom, he was licensed to box an exhibition in São Paulo against a replacement brought in after the original opponent suffered a concussion. Silva was disqualified for head-butting, knocked unconscious in the brawl that followed, and afterwards described headaches and memory loss. Brazil’s national boxing council suspended him for 180 days for the brawl. Nothing in the public record suggests that anyone who cleared him to fight that night had considered what he had already told a federal judge about his brain. The paperwork knew The UFC’s lawyers had given this future a good deal of thought. In an offer to Eddie Alvarez, filed in the Bellator litigation in January 2013, Article XIV described mixed martial arts as an inherently dangerous activity capable of causing irreversible neurological trauma, disability or death. It sought sweeping releases, covering claims of negligence and even gross negligence, and tried to limit the fighter’s recovery to the insurance benefits the agreement provided. The company was imagining what could happen to a fighter and deciding in advance where the responsibility would fall. By 2021 the language had become more clinical. Taila Santos, a former UFC flyweight title challenger, was involved in a lawsuit in Brazil that had nothing to do with brain injury. Bout-agreement forms filed in that case list, by name, the risks the fighter accepts: chronic traumatic encephalopathy, dementia, cognitive impairment and lost income. The next provision tries to release injury claims and confine the fighter’s benefits to specified insurance proceeds. The signature fields on the filed copies are blank, which limits what the forms can prove about any particular contract. It does not limit what they reveal about the people who drafted them. Permanent neurological harm was foreseeable enough to receive their careful attention. The public statements over the same years make the contrast plain. In 2013, Dana White described MMA under proper medical supervision as “the safest sport in the world, fact.” In January 2021, asked about reporting on Spencer Fisher’s neurological decline, he said, “we’re all learning every day about the brain injury stuff.” That June, at the UFC 263 post-fight press conference in Glendale, Arizona, White questioned whether any job offered health care forever after someone left. “I mean, that’s pretty crazy,” he said. In the same year, the company’s bout forms listed CTE and dementia among the risks a fighter was assuming. Medical science still had questions to answer. The company had interests to protect, and the contract drafting protected them thoroughly. White also acknowledged that Fisher would not be the last to suffer this way, and called it “part of the gig.” Four words dispose of consequences that can occupy the rest of a life. They also leave the obvious question unanswered. When the gig leaves a fighter needing continuing care, where does the promotion’s obligation begin? The risk is not the argument None of this is an argument against fighting. Every sport takes a toll. Sprinters tear hamstrings, hurdlers wreck their knees and ankles, and lightly built track athletes break collarbones that were never strengthened to absorb impact. Anyone who competes at the highest level accepts that the body may give out. Combat sports differ in one obvious respect: elsewhere, injury is something that goes wrong, while in fighting the opponent’s head is a legitimate scoring target. Even so, the danger is not the scandal. Fighters know the work is dangerous, and many choose it gladly. The scandal is what happens to the cost of that danger once the cheering stops. Seen plainly, the arrangement is a workplace. A promotion sells a show. Paying customers buy tickets and subscriptions to watch it, and broadcasters pay billions for the rights. The performers’ bodies are what the business sells. If a stagehand falls from a rig during that show, a framework of law asks who was responsible and who pays. A stunt performer on a union film set works under negotiated safety rules, is covered by workers’ compensation, and accrues health and pension credit. The fighter in the main event, the person everyone bought a ticket to see, is an independent contractor who arranges and pays for their own protection. If that fighter dies in the cage, or leaves it with an injury that never heals, the honest answer to the question of who pays is the fighter, and then the family. The government agency responsible for workplace safety has largely stayed out. OSHA has said it has no specific standards protecting professional athletes during competition and generally takes no enforcement action involving them. The agency has proposed excluding from General Duty Clause enforcement hazards it considers inherent and inseparable from the professional activity itself. The proposal remains pending. Workers’ compensation is the bargain American law struck a century ago so that injured workers would not be left destitute, and it does not reach a worker classified as a contractor. In most industries, the rules of the workplace were written in blood. In this one the workplace is the cage, and the rules depend on goodwill. Some will say MMA is young and these protections take time. The UFC turned 33 this month. The NFL was 36 when its players organised, and the NHL was 50. Neither league granted those protections because it had matured; the players forced them. The sport’s age explains none of this, and organisation explains all of it. There is no reason to wait another generation of damaged fighters before deciding that the people who put on the show deserve what workers everywhere else won long ago. The risk is inherent in the sport. Leaving the fighter to absorb all of it is a business choice, and choices can be changed. Fisher and the limits of goodwill Steven Marrocco’s 2021 investigation for MMA Fighting followed Fisher and his family into that question. The UFC paid for a specialist visit and gave Fisher a promotional-services arrangement worth $5,000 a month. In January 2017, the UFC told the Fishers it would let the agreement expire on April 30. According to Marrocco, the family had asked about using the promotion’s accident insurance and was told the potential injury fell outside its coverage. Neurologist Rodney Short had declared Fisher “permanently disabled and unable to work.” His family was left to manage his condition, the lost income and the end of the arrangement that had helped keep them afloat. An executive can arrange a payment or a job, and another executive can end it. People with neurological impairment need care that survives a change of ownership, a budget meeting and the departure of whoever used to take their calls. Gratitude for help already received does not pay the next bill. Fisher’s case makes that painfully clear, because the help was real and his need outlasted it. TKO’s securities filings set out where its event participants stand. They are independent contractors, responsible for maintaining their own health, disability and life insurance. The company describes accident and event coverage that may apply, and says it may bear certain medical costs itself. In the same filings it warns investors that sports organisations have been sued over alleged long-term neurocognitive impairment. So the company discloses the liability to its shareholders and assigns the cost of the injury to its fighters. A fighter whose neurological problems emerge after release or retirement must establish whether the circumstances fit a policy, a separate benefit or a decision by the company to pay. The people who designed that arrangement are responsible for the protection it provides and the gaps it leaves. Independent-contractor status is a business structure, and it has consequences for human beings. What the research says The UFC has also helped pay for research that makes those consequences harder to shrug off. In October it announced another $1 million commitment to the Cleveland Clinic’s Professional Athletes Brain Health Study through 2030, taking its total commitments above $3 million. The clinic says more than 900 active and retired athletes have enrolled. Participation is voluntary, and the assessments, including repeat MRI, are free. The work deserves support, and its findings should shape what happens to the people whose brains make the research necessary. Those findings are not reassuring. A 2015 analysis of 131 MMA fighters and 93 boxers linked greater fight exposure to smaller volumes in brain structures including the thalamus, and to slower processing speed. In 2022, researchers compared 45 men who had stopped sanctioned fighting and sparring with 45 matched men who had kept going. The men who stopped improved on cognitive measures, their levels of a blood marker associated with nerve-fibre injury fell, and their cortical thickness largely stabilised. The active group declined on some cognitive measures. The study was observational, but its practical lesson is clear: reducing exposure can matter while a fighter still has most of a life ahead. Notice who those cohorts were. Much of the evidence on repeated head impacts comes from male athletes, and the hockey brain-donor study discussed below was a study of men. The Cleveland study has not published its enrolment broken down by sex. Women now headline UFC cards, contest championships, and take the same strikes in the same gyms, yet the science that would tell them what a career costs has barely begun. Fighters cannot give informed consent to risks the research has not measured. The finding about reduced exposure belongs in every gym where hard sparring is treated as proof of seriousness. A professional record counts bouts and leaves out much of the work it took to get to them. It omits the rounds spent preparing a teammate, the symptoms trained through and the blows absorbed with no purse and no referee. Researchers using instrumented mouthguards have verified head impacts in training as well as competition. A commission may know exactly when a fighter last competed and very little about what that fighter’s head has endured since. A respectable record can sit on top of a punishing working history that never enters the official account. CTE adds a particular cruelty. A definitive diagnosis requires examining brain tissue after death, while the person who needs help has to go on living. A fighter can have persistent neurological impairment and cognitive problems that need treatment while clinicians are still investigating the cause. A family trying to obtain care can be living with obvious difficulty long before the medical work exists to explain it. MRI and neurological examination can identify structural concerns. Repeated cognitive testing can document changes in memory, processing speed and other functions. Blood markers such as neurofilament light and GFAP are being studied for what they might reveal about injury and longer-term change. Yet a normal structural scan can accompany a concussion, and no available test can say how many more blows a particular brain can safely take. That places a heavy responsibility on whoever decides when contact resumes, and the uncertainty should make them pay closer attention to the athlete in front of them. The Association of Ringside Physicians recommends at least 30 days away from competition and sparring after a head-strike TKO, 60 days after a knockout without loss of consciousness, and 90 days after a knockout with loss of consciousness, along with specialist clearance. Its imaging guidance recommends a baseline MRI and repeat imaging at least every three years when earlier scans are normal. Those recommendations depend on someone recognising symptoms, recording the injury, stopping contact and verifying recovery. Between publishing sensible guidance and making sure a fighter actually follows it, there is room for a great many rounds of sparring. Money makes that gap more dangerous. A medical suspension can delay a purse after a fighter has already paid for a camp. Rent still comes due, food still costs money, and the chance to be booked again can feel more urgent than a medical problem whose full consequences are still years away. A system that asks fighters to report symptoms honestly has to reckon with what honesty can cost them. Promotions, commissions and coaches all bear responsibility here. Telling a fighter to make the right decision is cheap advice when the fighter alone has to pay for it. What organised athletes have Football and hockey have spent years confronting the damage that follows athletes out of the building, and their arrangements give combat sports something concrete to examine, beginning with the initials attached to the programmes. The NFLPA and NHLPA are players’ unions, with a say in the conditions under which athletes work, receive treatment and return to competition. The published NFL–NFLPA concussion protocol uses video spotters and unaffiliated neurotrauma consultants, and requires independent neurological confirmation before a player returns to full participation. Eligible former players can apply for collectively bargained benefits, including the 88 Plan and neurocognitive disability benefits, and the concussion settlement offers qualifying former players another route. Hockey’s published protocol gives central and in-arena spotters a role in identifying players who need evaluation, with the club physician responsible for diagnosis and clearance. A 2024 study of 77 male hockey brain donors found CTE in 42, including 27 of the 28 who had played professionally. Within that selected sample, each additional year of play was associated with 34 percent higher odds of the disease. The finding adds to the evidence that a long working life of repeated exposure matters, including impacts never diagnosed as concussions. Elite rugby has taken the question into training, publishing contact-load guidance and building instrumented mouthguards into its head-injury assessment system. The training environment can be scrutinised wherever the people responsible decide to scrutinise it. The support extends to addiction, mental health and the hard work of getting well enough to work again. When Spencer Knight entered the NHL–NHLPA Player Assistance Program in February 2023, the joint announcement specified that he would keep receiving his salary during treatment and return when the programme’s administrators cleared him. The NFL and NFLPA announced a Behavioral Health Network in August. It launched in September and gives eligible current and former players and their dependents confidential outpatient care, with no coinsurance and no limit on visits. These are arrangements an athlete can use while a problem is being treated, with people assigned to help them get the care. The unions also take part in systems that demand something of the athlete. The NFLPA’s Player Affairs Department jointly administers the substance-of-abuse and performance-enhancing-substance policies with the league’s management council. The NHL’s jointly run assistance programme can impose serious consequences. In May 2024, Valeri Nichushkin was placed in Stage 3 and suspended without pay for at least six months before he could apply for reinstatement. Treatment, return-to-work decisions and discipline all run through agreed structures. Supporting players includes helping to write the rules for difficult cases and making sure the employer is bound by those rules too. That is what organised fighters could seek to negotiate: who makes medical decisions, what happens to income during treatment, and what care survives a career. Mark Hunt was calling for a fighters’ association in July 2016, after the Brock Lesnar doping controversy, and connecting safety, benefits and a voice in the rules that govern fighters’ lives. Leslie Smith’s Project Spearhead pursued organising and challenged the UFC’s treatment of fighters as independent contractors. The National Labor Relations Board’s regional director dismissed Smith’s retaliation charge without deciding whether she was an employee under federal labour law. The agency denied her appeal on 27 November 2018. The MMAFA has pursued advocacy, antitrust litigation and legislative protections by a different route. These efforts carry different legal powers, but the same question runs through all of them: who gets a meaningful say over the terms? The promotion has a financial interest in the answer. Funding treatment and continuing benefits costs money, and joint oversight requires management to negotiate decisions it would rather make alone. A profitable promotion can keep earning while accepting both larger obligations and a smaller share for itself. Its discomfort with that prospect is no reason for fighters to give up the chance to negotiate. There will always be someone willing to spend an evening arguing whether MMA is safer than boxing, football or hockey. Studies using different populations, injury definitions and exposure measures cannot settle that argument with a single ranking. Meanwhile, the questions a promotion can answer about its own fighters remain answerable. Who makes the medical decision? What happens to the fighter’s income? What care continues after release? How does the family claim it? The relative hazards of an NHL career offer little comfort to a retired fighter trying to pay a neurologist. The money The money available to answer those questions is recorded with far less ambiguity. The UFC reported $1.502 billion in revenue and $851 million in Adjusted EBITDA for 2025. TKO returned more than $1.3 billion to equity holders through buybacks, dividends and related distributions across the group. Its new research commitment is $1 million through 2030. Spread evenly across the five years from 2026 to 2030, that is an annual average of $200,000, about 0.024 percent of the UFC’s 2025 Adjusted EBITDA. On earnings of that size, a continuing neurological-care benefit belongs in the business plan. Eligibility can be defined, independent assessments arranged, treatment specified and funding committed. These are decisions a company can make. Shareholders receive detailed accounts of what the business earns and what it returns to them. Fighters and their families deserve the same clarity about what they can claim when the activity that produces those earnings leaves them needing help. California has built a statutory mechanism that deserves attention. Governor Gavin Newsom signed AB 1136 in October 2023, creating the Mixed Martial Arts Retirement Benefit Fund. Vesting requires 39 scheduled rounds in qualifying California professional contests. Ordinary distributions begin at 50, with provision for discretionary early benefits in specified circumstances. The state recorded $29,640.84 in deposits to the fund in fiscal 2025–26, against UFC worldwide revenue of $1.502 billion in calendar 2025. A full year’s contributions, in the largest MMA market in the country, came to little more than one debuting UFC fighter’s purse of $12,000 to show and $12,000 to win. The fund draws contributions from qualifying events across all promotions, through ticket assessments and other authorised sources. Its records show a further $18,276.16 deposited for fiscal 2026–27 through 11 September. The next questions are how the assessments were calculated, whether the amounts remitted match what was owed, what has accrued to fighters and whether any benefits have been paid. Ticket manifests, remittance statements, ledgers and benefit records should answer them. California has built something other jurisdictions should study, and its commission owes fighters a clear account of what that something delivers. Sooner or later, a pension fund has to produce a pension. Arizona’s statute shows how narrowly another kind of protection can be drawn. It requires $20,000 in primary medical coverage for injuries sustained in the ring and $50,000 in accidental-death coverage. The promoter pays the premium and any deductible above $25, and the law requires a copy of the insurance contract to be filed with the state. A ringside injury comes with a date, a place and an event. A neurological condition identified years later can involve an entire history of competition and training. Somewhere in that filed policy are the words that decide whether such a claim fits, which exclusions apply and whether a former fighter has any route to coverage. Those words deserve at least as much public attention as the announcement that a promotion insures its athletes. The rules of the fight over the rules Even the route to challenging the company has become a legal dispute in its own right. In Cirkunovs v. Zuffa, filed in May 2025, fighters challenged the arbitration clauses and class-action waivers in their contracts. TKO’s September 2026 disclosure says the case is stayed while the company appeals an order allowing discovery into the arbitration provisions. Whether those clauses would reach a neurological-injury claim is unsettled. The outcome matters well beyond antitrust. The pay litigation showed what the public can learn when fighters’ experiences enter a shared court record. Separate, private proceedings can leave people with the same problem each trying to prove it alone. The UFC has shown a sustained interest in the rules that govern its business. In congressional testimony in 2017, its regulatory executive Marc Ratner opposed extending the Muhammad Ali Boxing Reform Act to MMA. In 2026, Brownstein Hyatt’s lobbying disclosure for Zuffa listed the proposed boxing revival legislation among its issues and reported $150,000 in quarterly lobbying income for work that also covered piracy and visas. On 19 November, the Senate passed an amended version of H.R. 4624, containing medical-examination and match-injury insurance requirements alongside a framework for unified boxing organisations. The House received it the following day and adjourned without voting on the amendment. As the company expands into boxing, it has helped shape the federal rules for that business. MMA fighters still have no equivalent of the Ali Act’s protections. The company clearly understands the value of having a hand in how responsibility is written into law. Its competitors owe their fighters the same explanation of what survives a career. Bellator and GLORY were represented through Spike TV in an earlier Cleveland Clinic funding effort, and Top Rank and Golden Boy also supported that work. The combined MVP–PFL business promotes a fighter-first philosophy. ONE has publicly described its medical safeguards. Each can say what remains available after release, what covers a condition diagnosed later, and what happens when following medical advice ends a fighter’s earning life. “Fighter-first” is an attractive promise. Its real test comes when the fighter can no longer contribute to the gate. The public record reviewed for this article contains no general promise from any of those promotions that a former fighter’s later neurological care will be covered. That gap should worry active fighters negotiating their next agreement as much as the veterans already seeking help. Independent neurological assessment, income protection when medical advice stops a fight, and care for conditions that emerge after a career all belong in those negotiations, while the fighter still has something the promotion wants. The court record shows what can happen afterwards. A fighter develops problems that make work harder, then discovers that getting care requires money that can no longer be reliably earned. The family absorbs the lost income, the appointments and the work of caregiving. In the antitrust case, a settlement over pay became a possible way to meet needs that retirement had left unmet. The people running the sport have had years to consider that outcome, and their own paperwork shows that they did. The contracts gave the risk explicit attention in their warnings and attempted releases. Those living with the consequences deserve an equally explicit commitment to their care. If permanent brain damage is part of the gig, the bill belongs on the desk of the people profiting from it. Sources Le v. Zuffa, plaintiffs’ memorandum in support of settlement (7 October 2024), especially PDF pages 37–39, quoting the declarations of Wanderlei Silva (ECF 1045-12), Cung Le (1045-13), Shane Carwin (1045-14) and Jorge Rivera (1045-18). Filed memorandum Jessica Aguilar’s declaration (ECF 1047-33), excerpts published by Sports Illustrated (12 October 2024), and contemporary reporting on the Rodriguez bout. Sports Illustrated · Sherdog Bellator Sport Worldwide v. Alvarez, No. 2:13-cv-00063 (D.N.J., filed 3 January 2013), Document 1-1, proposed UFC agreement, Article XIV. Proposed agreement Santos litigation compilation, case 5023009-13.2021.8.24.0005/SC, Event 39, CONTR7, Section 5(a)–(b). Filed bout forms Brazilian National Boxing Council announcements and contemporaneous Brazilian reporting on Spaten Fight Night 2 (September 2025). Steven Marrocco’s Spencer Fisher investigation (12 January 2021), and White’s January 2021 response. MMA Fighting · White’s response White’s 2013 safety remarks and the UFC 263 post-fight press conference in Glendale, Arizona (June 2021), at 24:19–24:33. 2013 reporting · UFC recording OSHA interpretation letters on professional athletes (23 June 2003 and 12 September 2008) and proposed rule on the General Duty Clause, docket OSHA-2025-0041, RIN 1218-AD71. OSHA rulemaking and hearing status · Unified Agenda Sherdog, “The Fight as an Independent Contractor,” and Pace Intellectual Property, Sports & Entertainment Law Forum (2017) on fighter classification. League and players’ association founding records for the NFL (1920), NFLPA (1956), NHL (1917) and NHLPA (1967), and UFC 1 (12 November 1993). TKO Group Holdings FY2025 annual report, FY2025 earnings release and Q3 2026 litigation disclosure. Annual report · Earnings release · Litigation disclosure Cleveland Clinic’s October 2026 announcement, Bernick et al. (2015), Zhuang et al. (2022), the 2025 biomarker study and the instrumented-mouthguard study. Cleveland Clinic · 2015 study · 2022 study · Biomarkers · Mouthguards CDC on repeated head impacts, NINDS TES consensus criteria and Association of Ringside Physicians concussion and imaging guidance. CDC · TES criteria · Concussion guidance · Imaging guidance NFL–NFLPA concussion protocol, collective bargaining agreement, concussion settlement and Behavioral Health Network announcement. Protocol · CBA · Settlement · Behavioral Health Network NHL–NHLPA concussion protocol, 2024 hockey brain-donor study and World Rugby head-injury assessment and contact-load guidance. NHL protocol · Hockey donor study · Rugby assessment · Contact-load guidance NHL–NHLPA announcements on Spencer Knight and Valeri Nichushkin, and NFLPA departmental responsibilities. Knight · Nichushkin · NFLPA Mark Hunt’s 20 July 2016 organising call as reproduced by MMA Fighting, Project Spearhead’s launch, Leslie Smith’s charge and appeal (NLRB case 04-CA-219498), and the MMAFA’s account of its work. Hunt · Project Spearhead · NLRB docket · MMAFA California Business and Professions Code §§ 18888.2, 18888.5 and 18888.6, and the California State Athletic Commission meeting packet (21 September 2026), PDF pages 12 and 53. Commission packet Arizona Revised Statutes §§ 5-228 and 5-233. Section 5-228 · Section 5-233 Cirkunovs v. Zuffa, complaint (D. Nev., May 2025). Complaint 2017 congressional hearing, Brownstein Hyatt Q2 2026 LD-2, Senate announcement and bill text (19 November 2026), and House floor proceedings (20 November 2026). House hearing · Lobbying disclosure · Senate announcement · Bill text · House Clerk’s floor summary 2014 Cleveland Clinic research-support announcement, MVP–PFL merger statement and ONE medical leadership interview. Research support · MVP–PFL · ONE UFC entry-level pay reporting.
Read full article on MMA Stalker →